Progress vs. Presence
Why Getting Back to Basics Matters
Aldous Huxley once wrote, “Medical Science has made such tremendous progress that there is hardly a healthy human left.” It is a stinging, thought-provoking critique. Huxley was a visionary who understood the double-edged sword of technological advancement. He saw that while we have made incredible strides in understanding the mechanics of the human body, we have often traded our fundamental well-being for the convenience of modern progress.
For those of us in the Pernicious Anaemia (PA) advocacy community, these words ring particularly true. We live in an era of high-tech diagnostics and synthetic solutions, yet many of us spend years fighting for a basic understanding of our symptoms. We find ourselves asking: Have we prioritised the complexity of the system over the health of the individual?
The Paradox of Progress
Modern medicine has given us tools to identify B12 deficiency and manage the neurological and physical impacts of pernicious anaemia. We are grateful for the science that stops us dying from this once fatal condition. However, Huxley’s insight forces us to look at the cost of this reliance.
While life expectancy has increased, and what was, at one time, a frankly horrible death sentence to have pernicious anaemia, we must reflect on the quality of that life that many now are simply asking for. For many with PA, “survival” isn’t enough; we want to thrive. True health isn’t merely the absence of a diagnosed disease or a blood test result that falls within a “normal” range. It is found in how we live, how we eat, interact, and how we care for the intricate balance between our bodies and minds.
Returning to the Source
Huxley’s warning is a call for balance. It suggests that the future of health may not lie solely in a lab, but in a return to simpler, more holistic practices. For a PA patient, “getting back to basics” might look like:
Listening to the body: Trusting your symptoms even when the technology (the blood test) says otherwise.
Nutrition as Foundation: Moving beyond just the “fix” of an injection for a patient’s B12 serum level to supporting gut health and nervous system through a deeper understanding of nutrition in the form of vitamins and minerals and their absorption and the role in health care at all ages.
Adopting Common Sense: Embracing the logical necessity of training patients to self-administer and allowing frequency of treatment that is dictated by the resolution of symptoms, rather than rigid, arbitrary calendar dates.
Progress and Preservation
As we continue to advocate for better awareness and more accurate testing for pernicious anaemia, we must also remain mindful of the fundamental aspects of human well-being. Innovation is vital, but it should never come at the expense of the wisdom which through experience and intelligence we, as a human society, already possess.
We are more than a collection of data points and serum levels. We are complex beings who require a balance of modern intervention and simple, basic care.
What do you think? Do you feel that modern medical progress has helped or hindered your journey with PA?
Take a look at our shop for access to seminars and merchandise to support our cause
For many GPs, it does seem as though technology has replaced human diagnostic skills. In the case of PA, there’s often a rigid adherence to ‘the levels’ and the agreed 3 monthlyfrequency of injection treatment, even when the patient is very clearly dwindling away before the doctor's eyes. A toxic combination of a lack of holistic training, rigid regional guidelines, and cost implications mean the patient and their symptoms often come last!